Our eHealth Love Affair is Going To Kill People

Posted by Dike Drummond MD

ehealth will kill people dike drummondOur eHealth Love Affair is Going To Kill People

I am disturbed by the current starry eyed  love affair with technology in healthcare.  This blind faith in computers over physicians is destined to kill people.

The “Future of Healthcare” discussions making viral pronouncements like, “80% of what doctors do can be replaced by computer algorithms and cell phone apps” are misguided and dangerous. Here’s why ...

The most important - and often life saving - clinical decisions are made by physicians who are doing things that cannot be replaced by an algorithm.

They are called HUNCHES

One of the first things a doctor does, immediately and unconsciously is make the this determination.

Is the patient

We call it a Hunch. It is so much more nuanced and sophisticated than that.

=> We use our whole body to get an energetic read on the patients presentation and story
=> Filter it through our entire history of clinical experience
=> For an instantaneous read on how urgent this situation could be

Sick or Not Sick

This immediate determination is key to how we proceed from that point forward. The signs are often very subtle if we are asked to explain why we think this is a sick person, yet this “read” of the patient is something all physicians are familiar with.

We all have at least half a dozen cases of Sick Patients where our immediate action saved a life then and there - or caused us to really dig into the case - above and beyond the usual workup - to find a diagnosis that would have been missed otherwise.

Just think back for a moment on the cases you can remember that presented in this way in your practice.

Now what if

... that same patient had fired up a cell phone app instead of calling or seeing  you. They are plugging through an algorithm they have been told is better than seeing a doctor, rather than giving you a call, driving to the ER or making an appointment.

The delay itself could cost them their life

The incorrect diagnosis the app gives them - remember these decision trees are based on probabilities and rare things happen all too often - can cause a delay in seeking a doctor’s opinion that can be fatal or have permanent and severe consequences.

The algorithms will work in the majority of cases  - until they get it wrong or delay the patient’s presentation.

People will die in these interactions with technology unnecessarily. It will not be common AND It will happen.

A cell phone app is an easy example to point out and yet other eHealth technologies are no better. A text message, email or even a video house call can deny the physician the ability to make the clean determination of Sick or Not Sick.

When a bad outcome happens, you will be left with ...
“I wouldn’t have missed this if I had been able to actually see and touch the patient


So instead of a love affair with tech and eHealth, let’s take a much more nuanced view of its proper place.

Let’s be more careful about how we present Tech in Healthcare in our articles and news programming. Let’s make sure there are plenty of points in the algorithms where the next option is “Go immediately to the ER” or “Call 911” or “Call your physician”.

Let’s always be aware of the exceptions to the normal presentations of disease and the rare and unusual ways people present when they are seriously ill. And let’s stop the irresponsible “ Tech is the Future and Doctors are now Obsolete”  mantras.

Tech has its place

Doctors have a vital role

And there are times when you are ill when you want to be sitting in front of a physician, not your smartphone.

On occasion, that decision to seek the care of a doctor can save your life.



What do you feel is the proper place for eHealth going forward?
What cases have you seen when your hunch saved a life or made a difficult diagnosis?



Tags: Dike Drummond MD